For Homeless, A Last Haven Is Demolished
By IAN FISHER
Published: August 18, 1993
Bulldozers yesterday plowed through one of the
oldest and last shantytowns in New York City, crushing into bits of
plywood and muddy rags one of the most visible symbols of homelessness
in Manhattan.
Officials said the encampment at the foot of the
Manhattan Bridge -- known for an 18-foot teepee that towered over wood
and tar paper shacks -- had become a fire hazard and was increasingly
plagued with drugs. The site, a knoll called the Hill, was one of many
semi-permanent communities created by homeless people in the 1980's in
spots from Columbus Circle to Tompkins Square Park to the United
Nations.
Yesterday morning, it became the latest to be ripped
down. Officials said its 50 or so occupants were uprooted for their own
safety. But advocates for the homeless saw political purposes in the
strike.
'It's Going to Be Rough Now'
"It's been the Dinkins administration policy to get
rid of any encampment that appears too visible on the political
landscape," said Ted Houghton of the Coalition for the Homeless.
"Unfortunately, they have not attacked any of the roots of homelessness.
What we've got now is more people on the street than ever, but more
spread out than ever before."
City officials and homeless advocates both said the
Hill -- known for nearly a decade as an orderly, if rough communal
encampment -- appeared to be the largest remaining shantytown in the
city. But it was small compared to an earlier settlement at Tompkins
Square Park, where as many as 200 people lived.
Not long after bulldozer treads bowled over the
teepee's bare and charred poles -- its mailbag skin was burned off last
year -- one 52-year-old resident said he would miss the Hill.
"It wasn't the best spot in the world, but at least
it was something," said the man, who calls himself Preacherman, as two
machines snorted through the settlement where he lived for three years.
"It's going to be rough now."
In an effort to soften the blow to residents, city
workers had visited the encampment daily since Thursday, offering
alternate shelter, medical help and admission to programs for drug or
alcohol abuse. About 15 residents accepted help, said Howard Salk, the
director of outreach for the newly created city Department of Homeless
Services.
Advocates for the homeless said the city acted too
swiftly, and the Coalition for the Homeless, which learned of the
decision to raze the Hill only on Monday, tried to block the destruction
in court. A judge declined a request for a restraining order, but the
city agreed in negotiations to store the property of any resident who
asked.
Many shantytown residents interviewed yesterday said
they wanted no part of the city's system of homeless shelters, but were
also not happy about returning to the streets where many had lived
before.
"You sleep out on the street and you've got to worry
about someone robbing you or setting you on fire," said Al Fell, 37,
who lived in a small hut at the Hill off and on for five years. "Here,
you don't have to worry about that."
Encampment Had Changed
The decision to demolish the Hill, which had slowly
spread to cover a 20,000-square-foot lot at Canal and Chrystie Streets
in Chinatown, was notable because the settlement had received so much
attention in newspaper and magazine articles about homelessness. In a
long New Yorker article two years ago, Joseph DePlasco, a spokesman for
the city Department of Transportation, which owns the land, said the
agency was taking "a reformist position" and had no plans to tear down
the shanties.
Yesterday, Mr. DePlasco said the encampment had
degenerated over the last year from a self-contained and self-sustaining
community to one that was a threat to itself and the area around it.
"There was more filth, it was more of an eyesore, there were sanitation problems," he said.
Concern began as long ago as May 1992, when an arson
fire tore through the Hill, killing a long-time resident, Yi-Po Lee,
and destroying 6 of the 15 or so structures, which were often lovingly
constructed and outfitted with sofabeds, televisions and hotplates.
Since then, officials said neighbors had complained
bitterly about an increase in drug use and sales in the camp -- a trade
which some of its residents confirmed yesterday. Last Thursday evening,
as workers from the city Human Resources Administration met with
residents to tell them that their homes would be torn down, a
drug-related shootout erupted in the settlement.
Early last week, after meetings among several city
agencies, the Fire Department inspected the camp and issued an order to
vacate the property on the grounds that it was a fire hazard. Michael
Kharfen, director of the Mayor's Community Assistance Unit, said the
decision was not aimed at the homeless themselves nor at shantytowns but
at unsafe conditions. Increase in People on Streets
"We do look at each of these situations individually
and very carefully and in this case the situation had deteriorated
considerably," he said. "We really determined that this was a serious
and critical public safety and fire hazard."
But Mr. Houghton, of the Coalition for the Homeless,
and other advocates said the Hill's destruction was part of a
continuing effort by Mayor David N. Dinkins to eradicate shantytowns and
disperse the homeless into smaller, less noticeable pockets around the
city, to minimize them as a political issue.
He said that a survey conducted by the Coalition
last year found an increase in the number of people living on the
streets not long after shanties and other, less permanent homeless
communities were razed at places like 72d Street and the West Side
Highway, Columbus Circle, the United Nations, Tompkins Square Park,
Pennsylvania Station and near the Port Authority Bus Terminal. He said
that more homeless people were also living in the boroughs outside of
Manhattan.
While conceding that the Hill was a fire hazard, Mr.
Houghton said his homeless organization only wanted more time to place
more of its residents into assistance programs.
There were fewer than 25 people in the Hill's
shanties when bulldozers and dump trucks arrived at 6 A.M. For five
hours, city workers searched for remaining residents and collected some
residents' possessions for safekeeping. Then the heavy equipment set to
work, digging out huge scoops of worn jackets, twisted bicycles and
splintered plywood. Wondering Where to Go
Destruction of one section was briefly halted after
workers dismantling a hut by hand heard a man inside, warning them
profanely to get away from his roof. The man apparently scurried out of
the shack, down a slope toward the East River, and the hut was crushed.
All day, homeless men milled around the sidewalk
across Canal Street complaining that their homes where being destroyed
and wondering where they would go. One man said he would return to his
wife in Brooklyn. Others said they would stay in Sara Delano Roosevelt
Park, across the street from the Hill. Louis Watson, 52, was reunited
with his white cat, Thomas, after the animal emerged from the debris.
Mr. Watson, who lived there for seven years, peeked
past the dump trucks at the opened shell of the seven-foot high hut he
built himself, mostly with materials he found on the streets.
"It's been enjoyable here because you don't have to
pay rent, you don't have the landlord harassing you," he said. "You want
to get drunk, you get drunk, whatever you want to do."
The site will now be fenced in, and Mr. DePlasco
said he hoped it would be turned into a community garden.
Photos: The oldest and largest shantytown in
Manhattan falling to bulldozers yesterday at the foot of the Manhattan
Bridge. The encampment's 50 or so occupants were uprooted in an
early-morning action that officials said was for their own safety. (pg.
B1); An 18-foot teepee towered over the wood and tar paper shacks of the
largest shantytown in Manhattan yesterday, shortly before bulldozers
moved in to tear down the encampment on orders of city officials.; The
rubble left when the site, known as the Hill, was razed near the foot of
the Manhattan Bridge. (pg. B4) (Photographs by Angel Franco/The New
York Times) Map of Manhattan showing site of Shantytown. (pg. B4)